My Favorite Murder Reviews

I ordered a shirt from myfavoritemurder.com i’m the kind of person who gets annoyed waiting for anything to ship, so I was already checking the tracking way too much. Thankfully, it showed up faster than I expected, and the tracking was easy to follow. I had a quick question about sizing before it went out, and support actually got back to me fast and sounded like a real person, not some canned response. Overall it was a smooth experience, and I’d order again.

I’ve been listening to My Favorite Murder for years, i don’t really get why some people are so quick to pick it apart. It’s just an easy podcast to settle into. The stories are interesting, and Karen and Georgia talk like actual people, which is a big part of why I’ve stuck with it.

Yeah, some episodes are definitely heavier than others, but I think they usually handle the balance well. The sound is good, the pacing works, and it’s still one of those shows I keep coming back to, even if not every episode is perfect...

I’ll admit, I’m a little hesitant to praise true crime stuff too much, because so much of it can feel gross or sensationalized. But I’ve been following My Favorite Murder for a while, and the reason I keep coming back is that they seem genuinely careful with the heavier parts.

They don’t treat victims like props in a story, which I appreciate. They talk about boundaries, mental health, and not turning killers into celebrities, and when they get something wrong, it actually feels like they try to listen instead of just brushing it off.

It’s still true crime, so I’m definitely not always in the mood for it, and I wouldn’t say it’s for everyone. But compared to a lot of shows and sites in this space, this one feels more respectful and self-aware. So yeah, somewhat begrudgingly, 5 stars.

I really love the show, so I was excited for this, but the hoodie just felt kinda thin. The print started cracking after like two washes, which was dissapointing. Shipping was totally fine, no issues there, I just don’t think it was worth the price for me.

I’ve ended up on myfavoritemurder.com a bunch of times, what keeps pulling me back is the people there. I’m not even totally sure how I got so invested in the community part, but it just feels warm and funny in a really natural way. Fans sharing stories, updates, and little inside jokes makes it feel more alive than I expected.

It’s not perfect or anything, and there are moments where I’m a little confused about where something is or what I clicked on, but weirdly that makes it feel more real to me. Overall it’s easy enough to use, and I like how connected everything feels. Five stars from me

I really like the hosts and their chemistry is easy to listen to, but some of the jokes just don’t land for me. At times it almost feels like I’m being nudged to find it funnier than I do. Still, it’s a decent listen overall.